In his book “Predictably
Irrational”, Dan Ariely details how humans believe that they are rational
and make decisions based on logic and reason, however, in reality, we are totally
illogical and act on emotion. In fact, a case can be made that humans use the logical part of our brain to justify the irrational decisions we make.
Behavioural Finance looks at
the decision-making process that we go through when making an investment. One
of the strongest factors influencing our decision making is loss aversion. We’d
rather choose something of lesser value or quality that we know will not
negatively impact us rather than choosing something that has the potential to
positively impact us. Guaranteed products play right into our loss aversion behaviour.
A guaranteed investment is
fairly straightforward. Most guaranteed investments are fixed for a 5-year
term, capital is guaranteed, and the return is not allowed to drop below a
certain percentage. It sounds like a winning formula until you look a little
deeper. The investment is a business transaction and the asset managers need to
ensure that they are getting paid and earning the return that they need to.
What do the asset managers do? Well, they often smooth the returns.
For example, you take out a
guaranteed investment for $10,000 that says that your return cannot be negative.
Your money is invested in a variety of investments including cash, bonds,
equities, and property. The upper limit of the return is set up by the asset
manager at 5% per annum. In this hypothetical example, after five years the
investment would have grown to $12,762.82, however, the actual return on the
investment was 7% or $14,025.52, with 2% going to the asset manager.
Some investors seek comfort
in these products even if for a short term when markets are volatile. Extensive
research done over decades shows that, over time, investing in equities delivers
the best return.
However, there are certain
situations when a guaranteed product is beneficial for an investor. A
guaranteed investment protects investors against downside risk, but at the cost
of any upside. The guaranteed investment does have a place in a retirement plan
for most investors that have not saved enough for retirement, or early
retirees that have years ahead of needing an income. The bottom line is that
medicine has evolved, and people are living longer so some investors get
comfort in this type of investments, but there is a price to pay so always check with your financial advisor and consider your risk aversion.